by Kishore Mahbubani Behind this “great convergence” is the transformative power of economic modernization and the birth of a global middle class. In Asia. The Great Convergence: Asia, the West, and the Logic of One World middle class that brings an unprecedented convergence of interests and perceptions, cultures and values. Kishore Mahbubani is optimistic. Yet Mahbubani, one of the most perceptive global commentators, also warns that a new. Kishore Mahbubani, The Great Convergence: Asia, the West, and the Logic of One World, New York: Public Affairs.
|Published (Last):||9 May 2004|
|PDF File Size:||7.64 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||7.63 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
November Volume 90, Issue 6 Pages iii—xi, — The world, according to Kishore Mahbubani, a former Singaporean diplomat and one of Asia’s most visible pundits, is becoming a safer, richer, more equal and overall better place.
In addition, “a consensual cluster of norms has been sweeping the globe and has been accepted by policymaking elites around the convergehce.
The remaining problems, Mahbubani says, can all be solved through stronger and reformed international institutions. Instead they all live in separate cabins on the same boat. But this boat has a problem. It has captains and crews, each claiming exclusive responsibility for one convergehce.
However, it has no captain or crew to take care kisshore the boat as a whole. Mahbubani is an impatient, somewhat rancorous big-picture writer, using many analogies and aphorisms, so he dedicates very little time to explain how exactly the changes he proposes should take place.
The Great Convergence: Asia, the West, and the Logic of One World
Few would disagree that the UN needs reforms, but how can we overcome convetgence many obstacles to get there? He proposes making Brazil, India and Nigeria permanent Security Council members and replacing the UK and France with a joint EU seat – an excellent proposal – yet are there any historic examples of great powers giving up institutional privilege without losing a war?
In many ways, The Great Convergence sounds eerily like Norman Angell’s The Great Illusionwhich argued that economic interdependence had made war all but impossible. Soon after its publication, however, World War I broke out in a profoundly interconnected Europe. Why exactly should things be different this time around? Why is the author so sure that a conflict between China mhbubani Japan is unthinkable?
His answer shows a worrying degree of elitism and unworldliness. Mahbubani simply reports how, during his debates at the World Economic Forum in Davos, global elites increasingly think alike. That misses the point in four important ways. Secondly, the idea that the world’s elites should all learn the same ideas is problematic: It is precisely the Cambridge, Massachusetts-centric worldview of many international institutions that has kept them from understanding diverging local perspectives.
Thirdly, even a Yale-educated leader will have to consider the immediate interests of domestic constituencies that empower them, which are usually not aligned with those of the champagne-sipping elites of Davos that have the capacity to look at global challenges from a long-term perspective.
The Great Convergence: Asia, the West, and the Logic of One World – Kishore Mahbubani
Finally, Mahbubani himself is a perfect example of how a non-Western elite trained in the United States may very well disagree with many Western values. He rightly criticized the United States for its lack of enlightened leadership, yet fails to mention the many shortcomings of China’s policies. The author has been one of the most forceful proponents of “Asian Values” emphasizing order, stability and authoritarianismarguing that the West places too much value on freedom, democracy and individualism.
While he no longer explicitly supports these ideas, he continues to speak of Asia as if it were a single, cohesive mahbuabni. Yet how exactly do the values India cherishes align with those of China’s society? Many thinkers in Asia would disagree with the notion of a unified set of Asian values.
Few of the ideas presented in The Great Convergence are truly original and the book is filled with truisms and soundbites that, at closer inspection, make little convergenxe “We will increasingly realize that our village is a world and not that our world is a village”.
The Great Convergence – Kishore Mahbubani
And yet, given the scarcity of books on global order written outside of Europe and the United States, it is likely to gain a considerable readership around the world. Despite its flaws, The Great Convergence may help Western scholars obtain a glimpse at non-Western perspectives, which continue to be greatly underrepresented in the international debate.
International Politics in Ten Predictions under EnglishFeatured. Book reviews, Mahbuhani, Global governance. You might also like Book review: He is the author of IBSA: The rise of the Global South?
He is currently writing a book on Brazil’s role in Latin American politics.